-
By using Productive Talk Moves effectively, you can improve the effectiveness of your classroom conversations.
-
The goal of class discussions is for the teacher to facilitate student talk, not for the teacher to talk.
-
Productive Talk Moves are designed to help you achieve this goal.
-
For more info on Productive Talk Moves, check out the resources at the bottom of this tip.
-
When you call on students, your goal is to have them respond to each other.
-
Be careful not to respond to students yourself after you call on them. This is the perfect time to call on another student.
-
This is a crucial part of productive class engagement.
-
Below are the nine talk Productive Talk Moves to use while leading a discussion from Inquiry Project:
-
Time to Think.
-
Provide wait time or time for students to write down their answers before the discussion.
-
Say More.
-
Ask students to clarify what they just said, to say more.
-
So Are You Saying…?
-
Restate what you think the student said.
-
Who can Rephrase or Repeat?
-
Ensure that other students are listening and understanding by asking them to recite a recent point a student made.
-
Ask for Evidence or Reasoning.
-
Push students to explain why their answer is correct by forcing them to share their thinking outloud.
-
Challenge or Counterexample.
-
Have students think about exceptions or where their idea might be wrong or exceptions to their idea.
-
Agree/Disagree and Why.
-
Ask other students to take a position and defend it in response to a point an other students just made.
-
Add On.
-
Ask other students to provide more information, such as if there are multiple examples of a phenomenon.
-
Doing this can get students to come up with a lot more examples.
-
Explain What Someone Else Means.
-
Ensure that students are not only listening, but also understanding their classmates.
-
It’s important to ask well crafted open-ended question that lead to discussion and debate.
-
Use open-ended questions rather than asking a question to which there could be one best answer.
-
Asking a question that anticipate a single best answer is called IRE (Interrogation, Response, Evaluation) sometimes known as guess what’s in my head.
-
Consider the following example questions that use Productive Talk Moves for an in-class discussion about efficiency:
-
"We would agree that efficiency is good, but there are many debatable elements to efficiency."
-
"There are multiple kinds of efficiency. Which is best? Speed? Size?"
-
"Can you ever maximize all kinds of efficiency?"
-
"Does it even matter if code is efficient?"
-
"What about less efficient code that is more readable?"
-
Ask a question tangential to the course content to teach students how to have class discussion in a low-stakes context.
-
Check out the Talk Science Primer for an easy to understand and free resource: http://inquiryproject.terc.edu/shared/pd/TalkScience_Primer.pdf
-
Get more information on Productive Talk Moves, as well as videos demonstrating them, at http://inquiryproject.terc.edu/
-
The Productive Talk Moves and the student engagement in inquiry are extremely appropriate to computer science at all levels.
-
Though the videos and the project are aimed at 3rd to 5th grade science classes, they can be incredibly powerful in your classroom.
- Programming is a form of inquiry, as students test what the computer will do with their code.